Cesare Tronci

Dr Cesare Tronci


Associate Professor
+44 (0)1483 683356
16 AA 04

Academic and research departments

School of Mathematics and Physics.

About

Research

Research interests

Research grants

Leverhulme Trust Grant II

In 2023, I was awarded the 3-year Leverhulme Research Grant “Solute motion in complex fluids: mathematics and solvation dynamics”. Total budget: £405K. Co-investigators: Irene Burghardt (Frankfurt, DE), François Gay-Balmaz (Paris, FR), Raymond Kapral (Toronto, CA).

Templeton Grant

Since 12/2021, I am Co-Investigator in the interdisciplinary project “Life on the Edge: quantum thermodynamics, quantum biology and the arrow of time” funded by the Templeton Foundation (USA). This project is funded with $3M over 2.5 years. Principal Investigators: Jim Al-Khalili (Surrey, UK), Andrea Rocco (Surrey, UK).

Royal Society Int'l Exchanges Grant

In 2020, I was awarded a 2-year travel grant by the Royal Society under the scheme International Exchanges. This is a £12K award is to support a collaboration with Giovanni Manfredi at the Strasbourg Institute of Material Sciences (France).

Humboldt Fellowship

In 2019, I was awarded a 10-month fellowship by the Humboldt Foundation (Germany) under the scheme Humboldt Research Fellowship for Experienced Researchers. This award covered salary and expenses during my work within the Numerical Algorithms & Methods Division at the Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics in Garching bei München.

Leverhulme Trust Grant I

In 2014, I was awarded the 4-year Leverhulme Research Grant “From geometry to kinetic-fluid systems (and back)”. Total budget: £252K. Co-investigators: Giovanni Lapenta (Leuven, BE), Philip J. Morrison (Austin, US), Emanuele Tassi (Nice, FR).

London Mathematical Society Network

During 2013-2018, I was awarded a series of grants from the London Mathematical Society to lead the Network in Applied Geometric Mechanics, involving research groups at Brunel University, Imperial College, and the University of Surrey. This network is now run by Exeter University and also involves the University of Edinburgh. I continue to serve as the local coordinator at Surrey.

Small awards

Over the last 10 years, I have been awarded a series of small grants (<£4K) by the London Mathematical Society, the Institute of Mathematics and Applications, and the internal Faculty Research Support Fund at the University of Surrey.

 

Selected invited talks

Koopman wavefunctions and mixed quantum-classical dynamics of pure-dephasing systems. Exact Factorization, Geometric Phase and Bohmian mechanics, 19-20 September 2022, Bristol, UK

Multi-physics models for hybrid kinetic-fluid and classical-quantum systems, Hamiltonian Systems, from Topology to Applications through Analysis I, 8-12 October 2018, Mathematical Sciences Research Institute, Berkeley CA, USA

Symmetry methods for quantum variational principles and expectation value dynamics, PACM Colloquium, Princeton University, November 6 2017, Princeton NJ, USA

Variational formulations of low frequency kinetic-MHD in the current-coupling scheme, Mini-conference on "New Developments in Algorithms and Verification of Gyro Kinetic Simulations", 58th Annual Meeting of the APS Division of Plasma Physics, October 31 - November 4, 2016, San Jose CA, USA. (Solicited talk)

Modeling efforts in hybrid kinetic-MHD and fully kinetic theories, Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, October 27 2016, Princeton NJ, USA

Multiphysics models for hybrid kinetic-fluid systems, Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, New York University, April 7 2016, New York NY, USA

Classical-quantum variational principles, Classic and Stochastic Geometric Mechanics Workshop, June 8-11, 2015, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Switzerland

Relabeling symmetry in fluid dynamics, Geometry and Fluids, April 7-11 2014, Clay Mathematics Institute, Oxford, UK

Hydrodynamic vorticity and helicity of conservative liquid crystal flows, Isaac Newton Institute for Mathematical Sciences, June 11 2103, Cambridge, UK

Geometry and symmetry in multi-physics models for magnetized plasmas, Fields Institute for Research in Mathematical Sciences, July 9 2012, Toronto, Canada

Teaching

Publications

Paul Bergold, Cesare Tronci (2023)Madelung Transform and Variational Asymptotics in Born-Oppenheimer Molecular Dynamics, In: Geometric Science of Informationpp. 231-241 Springer Nature Switzerland

While Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics (BOMD) has been widely studied by resorting to powerful methods in mathematical analysis, this paper presents a geometric formulation in terms of Hamilton’s variational principle and Euler-Poincaré reduction by symmetry. Upon resorting to the Lagrangian hydrodynamic paths made available by the Madelung transform, we show how BOMD arises by applying asymptotic methods to the variational principles underlying different continuum models and their particle closure schemes. In particular, after focusing on the hydrodynamic form of the fully quantum dynamics, we show how the recently proposed bohmion scheme leads to an on-the-fly implementation of BOMD. In addition, we extend our analysis to models of mixed quantum-classical dynamics.

François Gay-Balmaz, Cesare Tronci (2023)Fluid models of mixed quantum-classical dynamics, In: arXiv.org Cornell University Library, arXiv.org

Several efforts in nonadiabatic molecular dynamics are based on Madelung's hydrodynamic description of nuclear motion, while the electronic component is treated as a finite-dimensional quantum system. As the quantum potential in Madelung hydrodynamics leads to severe challenges, one often seeks to neglect its contribution thereby approximating nuclear motion as classical. Then, the resulting model couples classical hydrodynamics for the nuclei to the quantum motion of the electronic component. Such mixed quantum-classical fluid models have also appeared in solvation dynamics to describe the coupling between liquid solvents and the quantum solute molecule. While these approaches represent a promising direction, their mathematical structure requires a certain care. In some cases, challenging second-order gradients make these equations hardly tractable. In other cases, these models are based on phase-space formulations that suffer from well-known consistency issues. Here, we present new quantum-classical fluid system that resolves these issues. Unlike common approaches, the current system is obtained by applying the fluid closure at the level of the action principle of the original phase-space model, thereby inheriting variational and Hamiltonian structures, and ensuring energy/momentum balance. After discussing some of its structural properties and dynamical invariants, we illustrate the proposed fluid model in the case of pure-dephasing systems. We conclude with a presentation of some invariant planar models.

Cesare Tronci, François Gay-Balmaz (2023)Lagrangian Trajectories and Closure Models in Mixed Quantum-Classical Dynamics, In: Geometric Science of Informationpp. 290-300 Springer Nature Switzerland

Mixed quantum-classical models have been proposed in several contexts to overcome the computational challenges of fully quantum approaches. However, current models typically suffer from long-standing consistency issues, and, in some cases, invalidate Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. Here, we present a fully Hamiltonian theory of quantum-classical dynamics that appears to be the first to ensure a series of consistency properties, beyond positivity of quantum and classical densities. Based on Lagrangian phase-space paths, the model possesses a quantum-classical Poincaré integral invariant as well as infinite classes of Casimir functionals. We also exploit Lagrangian trajectories to formulate a finite-dimensional closure scheme for numerical implementations.

Jonathan I. Rawlinson, Cesare Tronci (2020)Regularized Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics, In: Physical Review A American Physical Society

While the treatment of conical intersections in molecular dynamics generally requires nonadiabatic approaches, the Born-Oppenheimer adiabatic approximation is still adopted as a valid alternative in certain circumstances. In the context of Mead-Truhlar minimal coupling, this paper presents a new closure of the nuclear Born-Oppenheimer equation, thereby leading to a molecular dynamics scheme capturing geometric phase effects. Specifically, a semiclassical closure of the nuclear Ehrenfest dynamics is obtained through a convenient prescription for the nuclear Bohmian trajectories. The conical intersections are suitably regularized in the resulting nuclear particle motion and the associated Lorentz force involves a smoothened Berry curvature identifying a loop-dependent geometric phase. In turn, this geometric phase rapidly reaches the usual topological index as the loop expands away from the original singularity. This feature reproduces the phenomenology appearing in recent exact nonadiabatic studies, as shown explicitly in the Jahn-Teller problem for linear vibronic coupling. Likewise, a newly proposed regularization of the diagonal correction term is also shown to reproduce quite faithfully the energy surface presented in recent nonadiabatic studies.

Cesare Tronci, Francois Gay-Balmaz (2021)From Quantum Hydrodynamics to Koopman Wavefunctions II, In: F Nielsen, F Barbaresco (eds.), GEOMETRIC SCIENCE OF INFORMATION (GSI 2021)12829311pp. 311-319 Springer Nature

Based on the Koopman-van Hove (KvH) formulation of classical mechanics introduced in Part I, we formulate a Hamiltonian model for hybrid quantum-classical systems. This is obtained by writing the KvH wave equation for two classical particles and applying canonical quantization to one of them. We illustrate several geometric properties of the model regarding the associated quantum, classical, and hybrid densities. After presenting the quantum-classical Madelung transform, the joint quantum-classical distribution is shown to arise as a momentum map for a unitary action naturally induced from the van Hove representation on the hybrid Hilbert space. While the quantum density matrix is positive by construction, no such result is currently available for the classical density. However, here we present a class of hybrid Hamiltonians whose flow preserves the sign of the classical density. Finally, we provide a simple closure model based on momentum map structures.

Denys I. Bondar, François Gay-Balmaz, Cesare Tronci (2019)Koopman wavefunctions and classical-quantum correlation dynamics, In: Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences Royal Society

Upon revisiting the Hamiltonian structure of classical wavefunctions in Koopman-von Neumann theory, this paper addresses the long-standing problem of formulating a dynamical theory of classical-quantum coupling. The proposed model not only describes the influence of a classical system onto a quantum one, but also the reverse effect -- the quantum backreaction. These interactions are described by a new Hamiltonian wave equation overcoming shortcomings of currently employed models. For example, the density matrix of the quantum subsystem is always positive-definite. While the Liouville density of the classical subsystem is generally allowed to be unsigned, its sign is shown to be preserved in time for a specific infinite family of hybrid classical-quantum systems. The proposed description is illustrated and compared with previous theories using the exactly solvable model of a degenerate two-level quantum system coupled to a classical harmonic oscillator.

Cesare Tronci, E Bonet-Luz (2016)Hamiltonian approach to Ehrenfest expectation values and Gaussian quantum states, In: Proceedings of the Royal Society A472(2189) The Royal Society

The dynamics of quantum expectation values is considered in a geometric setting. First, expectation values of the canonical operators are shown to be equivariant momentum maps for the action of the Heisenberg group on quantum states. Then, the Hamiltonian structure of Ehrenfest’s theorem is shown to be Lie-Poisson for a semidirect-product Lie group, named the Ehrenfest group. The underlying Poisson structure produces classical and quantum mechanics as special limit cases. In addition, quantum dynamics is expressed in the frame of the expectation values, in which the latter undergo canonical Hamiltonian motion. In the case of Gaussian states, expectation values dynamics couples to second-order moments, which also enjoy a momentum map structure. Eventually, Gaussian states are shown to possess a Lie-Poisson structure associated to another semidirect-product group, which is called the Jacobi group. This structure produces the energy-conserving variant of a class of Gaussian moment models previously appeared in the chemical physics literature.

Alex Close, Joshua W Burby, Cesare Tronci (2018)A low-frequency variational model for energetic particle effects in the pressure-coupling scheme, In: Journal of Plasma Physics84(4)905840401 Cambridge University Press

Energetic particle effects in magnetic confinement fusion dev ices are commonly studied by hybrid kinetic-fluid simulation codes whose unde rlying continuum evolu- tion equations often lack the correct energy balance. While two different kinetic-fluid coupling options are available (current-coupling and pres sure-coupling), this paper applies the Euler-Poincar ́e variational approach to formu late a new conservative hybrid model in the pressure-coupling scheme. In our case th e kinetics of the en- ergetic particles are described by guiding center theory. T he interplay between the Lagrangian fluid paths with phase space particle trajectori es reflects an intricate variational structure which can be approached by letting th e 4-dimensional guiding center trajectories evolve in the full 6-dimensional phase space. Then, the redundant perpendicular velocity is integrated out to recover a four- dimensional description. A second equivalent variational approach is also reported, which involves the use of phase space Lagrangians. Not only do these variational st ructures confer on the new model a correct energy balance, but also they produce a cr oss-helicity invariant which is lost in the other pressure-coupling schemes report ed in the literature.

ARD Close, C Tronci (2015)Equivalent variational approaches to biaxial liquid crystal dynamics, In: PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY A-MATHEMATICAL PHYSICAL AND ENGINEERING SCIENCES471(2183)ARTN 20150 ROYAL SOC
F Gay-Balmaz, C Tronci (2010)Reduction theory for symmetry breaking with applications to nematic systems, In: Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena239(20-22)pp. 1929-1947 Elsevier

We formulate Euler–Poincaré and Lagrange–Poincaré equations for systems with broken symmetry. We specialize the general theory to present explicit equations of motion for nematic systems, ranging from single nematic molecules to biaxial liquid crystals. The geometric construction applies to order parameter spaces consisting of either unsigned unit vectors (directors) or symmetric matrices (alignment tensors). On the Hamiltonian side, we provide the corresponding Poisson brackets in both Lie–Poisson and Hamilton–Poincaré formulations. The explicit form of the helicity invariant for uniaxial nematics is also presented, together with a whole class of invariant quantities (Casimirs) for two-dimensional incompressible flows.

C Tronci (2010)Hamiltonian approach to hybrid plasma models, In: Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical43(37)
F Gay-Balmaz, C Tronci (2011)The helicity and vorticity of liquid-crystal flows, In: Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences467(2128)pp. 1197-1213

We present explicit expressions of the helicity conservation in nematic liquid-crystal flows, for both the Ericksen–Leslie and Landau–de Gennes theories. This is done by using a minimal coupling argument that leads to an Euler-like equation for a modified vorticity involving both velocity and structure fields (e.g. director and alignment tensor). This equation for the modified vorticity shares many relevant properties with ideal fluid dynamics, and it allows for vortex-filament configurations, as well as point vortices, in two dimensions. We extend all these results to particles of arbitrary shape by considering systems with fully broken rotational symmetry.

Bin Cheng, Endre Suli, Cesare Tronci (2017)Existence of Global Weak Solutions to a Hybrid Vlasov-MHD Model for Magnetized Plasmas, In: Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society115(4)pp. 854-896 London Mathematical Society

We prove the global-in-time existence of large-data nite-energy weak solutions to an incompressible hybrid Vlasov-magnetohydrodynamic model in three space dimensions. The model couples three essential ingredients of magnetized plasmas: a transport equation for the probability density function, which models energetic rare ed particles of one species; the incompressible Navier{Stokes system for the bulk uid; and a parabolic evolution equation, involving magnetic di usivity, for the magnetic eld. The physical derivation of our model is given. It is also shown that the weak solution, whose existence is established, has nonincreasing total energy, and that it satis es a number of physically relevant properties, including conservation of the total momentum, conservation of the total mass, and nonnegativity of the probability density function for the energetic particles. The proof is based on a one-level approximation scheme, which is carefully devised to avoid increase of the total energy for the sequence of approximating solutions, in conjunction with a weak compactness argument for the sequence of approximating solutions. The key technical challenges in the analysis of the mathematical model are the nondissipative nature of the Vlasov-type particle equation and passage to the weak limits in the multilinear coupling terms.

DD Holm, C Tronci (2009)The geodesic Vlasov equation and its integrable moment closures, In: Journal of Geometric Mechanics1(2)pp. 181-208

Various integrable geodesic flows on Lie groups are shown to arise by taking moments of a geodesic Vlasov equation on the group of canonical transformations. This was already known for both the one- and two-component Camassa-Holm systems. The present paper extends our earlier work to recover another integrable system of ODE's that was recently introduced by Bloch and Iserles. Solutions of the Bloch-Iserles system are found to arise from the Klimontovich solution of the geodesic Vlasov equation. These solutions are shown to form one of the legs of a dual pair of momentum maps. The Lie-Poisson structures for the dynamics of truncated moment hierarchies are also presented in this context.

J Gibbons, DD Holm, C Tronci (2008)Geometry of Vlasov kinetic moments: A bosonic Fock space for the symmetric Schouten bracket, In: Physics Letters, Section A: General, Atomic and Solid State Physics372(23)pp. 4184-4196
F Gay-Balmaz, TS Ratiu, C Tronci (2012)Euler-Poincare Approaches to Nematodynamics, In: ACTA APPLICANDAE MATHEMATICAE120(1)pp. 127-151 SPRINGER
DD Holm, C Tronci (2012)Euler-Poincaré formulation of hybrid plasma models, In: Communications in Mathematical Sciences10(1)pp. 191-222

Three different hybrid Vlasov-fluid systems are derived by applying reduction by symmetry to Hamilton's variational principle. In particular, the discussion focuses on the Euler- Poincaré formulation of three major hybridMHD models, which are compared in the same framework. These are the current-coupling scheme and two different variants of the pressure-coupling scheme. The Kelvin-Noether theorem is presented explicitly for each scheme, together with the Poincaré invariants for its hot particle trajectories. Extensions of Ertel's relation for the potential vorticity and for its gradient are also found in each case, as well as new expressions of cross helicity invariants.

Esther Bonet Luz, C Tronci (2015)Geometry and symmetry of quantum and classical-quantum variational principles, In: JOURNAL OF MATHEMATICAL PHYSICS56(8)ARTN 08210 AMER INST PHYSICS
C Tronci (2012)A Lagrangian kinetic model for collisionless magnetic reconnection, In: Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion

A new fully kinetic system is proposed for modeling collisionless magnetic reconnection. The formulation relies on fundamental principles in Lagrangian dynamics, in which the inertia of the electron mean flow is neglected in the expression of the Lagrangian, rather then enforcing a zero electron mass in the equations of motion. This is done upon splitting the electron velocity into its mean and fluctuating parts, so that the latter naturally produce the corresponding pressure tensor. The model exhibits a new Coriolis force term, which emerges from a change of frame in the electron dynamics. Then, if the electron heat flux is neglected, the strong electron magnetization limit yields a hybrid model, in which the electron pressure tensor is frozen into the electron mean velocity.

DD Holm, C Tronci (2009)Geodesic flows on semidirect-product Lie groups: Geometry of singular measure-valued solutions, In: Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences465(2102)pp. 457-476
C Tronci, E Tassi, PJ Morrison (2015)Energy-Casimir stability of hybrid Vlasov-MHD models, In: Journal of Physics A-Mathematical and Theoretical48(18)ARTN 18550 IOP PUBLISHING LTD
Cesare Tronci (2020)Variational mean-fluctuation splitting and drift-fluid models, In: arXiv.org Cornell University

After summarizing the variational approach to splitting mean flow and fluctuation kinetics in the standard Vlasov theory, the same method is applied to the drift-kinetic equation from Littlejohn’s theory of guiding-center motion. This process sheds a new light on driftordered fluid (drift-fluid) models, whose anisotropic pressure tensor is then considered in detail. In addition, current drift-fluid models are completed by the insertion of magnetization terms ensuring momentum conservation. Magnetization currents are also shown to lead to challenging aspects when drift-fluid models are coupled to Maxwell’s equations for the evolution of the electromagnetic field. In order to overcome these difficulties, a simplified guiding-center theory is proposed along with its possible applications to hybrid kinetic-fluid models.

AJ Brizard, C Tronci (2016)Variational formulations of guiding-center Vlasov-Maxwell theory, In: Physics of Plasmas23(6)

The variational formulations of guiding-center Vlasov-Maxwell theory based on Lagrange, Euler, and Euler-Poincaré variational principles are presented. Each variational principle yields a different approach to deriving guiding-center polarization and magnetization effects into the guiding-center Maxwell equations. The conservation laws of energy, momentum, and angular momentum are also derived by Noether method, where the guiding-center stress tensor is now shown to be explicitly symmetric.

Upon combining Northrop’s picture of charged particle motion with modern liquid crystal theories, this paper provides a new description of guiding center dynamics (to lowest order). This new perspective is based on a rotation gauge field (gyrogauge) that encodes rotations around the magnetic field. In liquid crystal theory, an analogue rotation field is used to encode the rotational state of rod-like molecules. Instead of resorting to sophisticated tools (e.g. Hamiltonian perturbation theory and Lie series expansions) that still remain essential in higher-order gyrokinetics, the present approach combines the WKB method with a simple kinematical ansatz, which is then replaced into the charged particle Lagrangian. The latter is eventually averaged over the gyrophase to produce Littlejohn’s guiding-center equations. A crucial role is played by the vector potential for the gyrogauge field. A similar vector potential is related to liquid crystal defects and is known as wryness tensor in Eringen’s micropolar theory.

Darryl D. Holm, Lennon Ó Náraigh, Cesare Tronci (2019)A geometric diffuse-interface method for droplet spreading, In: Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences476(2233) The Royal Society

This paper exploits the theory of geometric gradient flows to introduce an alternative regularization of the thin-film equation valid in the case of large-scale droplet spreading—the geometric diffuse-interface method. The method possesses some advantages when compared with the existing models of droplet spreading, namely the slip model, the precursor film method and the diffuse-interface model. These advantages are discussed and a case is made for using the geometric diffuse-interface method for the purpose of numerical simulations. The mathematical solutions of the geometric diffuse interface method are explored via such numerical simulations for the simple and well-studied case of large-scale droplet spreading for a perfectly wetting fluid— we demonstrate that the new method reproduces Tanner’s Law of droplet spreading via a simple and robust computational method, at a low computational cost. We discuss potential avenues for extending the method beyond the simple case of perfectly wetting fluids.

C Tronci, E Camporeale (2015)Neutral Vlasov kinetic theory of magnetized plasmas, In: PHYSICS OF PLASMAS22(2)ARTN 02070 AMER INST PHYSICS
DD Holm, V Putkaradze, C Tronci (2008)Geometric gradient-flow dynamics with singular solutions, In: Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena237(22)pp. 2952-2965

The gradient-flow dynamics of an arbitrary geometric quantity is derived using a generalization of Darcy’s Law. We consider flows in both Lagrangian and Eulerian formulations. The Lagrangian formulation includes a dissipative modification of fluid mechanics. Eulerian equations for self-organization of scalars, 1-forms and 2-forms are shown to reduce to nonlocal characteristic equations. We identify singular solutions of these equations corresponding to collapsed (clumped) states and discuss their evolution.

H. Alemi Ardakani, T.J. Bridges, F. Gay-Balmaz, Y.H. Huang, C. Tronci (2019)A variational principle for fluid sloshing with vorticity, dynamically coupled to vessel motion, In: Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences Royal Society

A variational principle is derived for two-dimensional incompressible rotational fluid flow with a free surface in a moving vessel when both the vessel and fluid motion are to be determined. The fluid is represented by a stream function and the vessel motion is represented by a path in the planar Euclidean group. Novelties in the formulation include how the pressure boundary condition is treated, the introduction of a stream function into the Euler- Poincaré variations, the derivation of free surface variations, and how the equations for the vessel path in the Euclidean group, coupled to the fluid motion, are generated automatically.

DD Holm, L O Náraigh, C Tronci (2009)Singular solutions of a modified two-component Camassa-Holm equation., In: Physical Review E (Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics)79(1)016601 American Physical Society

The Camassa-Holm (CH) equation is a well-known integrable equation describing the velocity dynamics of shallow water waves. This equation exhibits spontaneous emergence of singular solutions (peakons) from smooth initial conditions. The CH equation has been recently extended to a two-component integrable system (CH2), which includes both velocity and density variables in the dynamics. Although possessing peakon solutions in the velocity, the CH2 equation does not admit singular solutions in the density profile. We modify the CH2 system to allow a dependence on the average density as well as the pointwise density. The modified CH2 system (MCH2) does admit peakon solutions in the velocity and average density. We analytically identify the steepening mechanism that allows the singular solutions to emerge from smooth spatially confined initial data. Numerical results for the MCH2 system are given and compared with the pure CH2 case. These numerics show that the modification in the MCH2 system to introduce the average density has little short-time effect on the emergent dynamical properties. However, an analytical and numerical study of pairwise peakon interactions for the MCH2 system shows a different asymptotic feature. Namely, besides the expected soliton scattering behavior seen in overtaking and head-on peakon collisions, the MCH2 system also allows the phase shift of the peakon collision to diverge in certain parameter regimes.

Tomoki Ohsawa, Cesare Tronci (2017)Geometry and Dynamics of Gaussian Wave Packets and their Wigner Transforms, In: Journal of Mathematical Physics58(9)pp. 1-19 AIP Publishing

We find a relationship between the dynamics of the Gaussian wave packet and the dynamics of the corresponding Gaussian Wigner function from the Hamiltonian and symplecticgeometric point of view. The main result states that the momentum map corresponding to the natural action of the symplectic group on the Siegel upper half space yields the covariance matrix of the corresponding Gaussian Wigner function. This fact, combined with Kostant’s coadjoint orbit covering theorem, establishes a symplectic/Poisson-geometric connection between the two dynamics.

Francois Gay-Balmaz, Cesare Tronci (2020)Madelung transform and probability densities in hybrid classical-quantum dynamics, In: Nonlinearity IOP Publishing

This paper extends the Madelung-Bohm formulation of quantum mechanics to describe the time-reversible interaction of classical and quantum systems. The symplectic geometry of the Madelung transform leads to identifying hybrid classical-quantum Lagrangian paths extending the Bohmian trajectories from standard quantum theory. As the classical symplectic form is no longer preserved, the nontrivial evolution of the Poincaré integral is presented explicitly. Nevertheless, the classical phase-space components of the hybrid Bohmian trajectory identify a Hamiltonian flow parameterized by the quantum coordinate and this flow is associated to the motion of the classical subsystem. In addition, the continuity equation of the joint classical-quantum density is presented explicitly. While the von Neumann density operator of the quantum subsystem is always positive-definite by construction, the hybrid density is generally allowed to be unsigned. However, the paper concludes by presenting an infinite family of hybrid Hamiltonians whose corresponding evolution preserves the sign of the probability density for the classical subsystem.

DD Holm, V Putkaradze, C Tronci (2007)Geometric dissipation in kinetic equations, In: Comptes Rendus Mathematique345(5)pp. 297-302 Elsevier

A new symplectic variational approach is developed for modeling dissipation in kinetic equations. This approach yields a double bracket structure in phase space which generates kinetic equations representing coadjoint motion under canonical transformations. The Vlasov example admits measure-valued single-particle solutions. Such solutions are reversible; and the total entropy is a Casimir, and thus is preserved.

Michael S. Foskett, Darryl D. Holm, Cesare Tronci (2019)Geometry of nonadiabatic quantum hydrodynamics, In: Acta Applicandae Mathematicae162(1)pp. 63-103 Springer

The Hamiltonian action of a Lie group on a symplectic manifold induces a momentum map generalizing Noether's conserved quantity occurring in the case of a symmetry group. Then, when a Hamiltonian function can be written in terms of this momentum map, the Hamiltonian is called `collective'. Here, we derive collective Hamiltonians for a series of models in quantum molecular dynamics for which the Lie group is the composition of smooth invertible maps and unitary transformations. In this process, different fluid descriptions emerge from different factorization schemes for either the wavefunction or the density operator. After deriving this series of quantum fluid models, we regularize their Hamiltonians for finite ℏ by introducing local spatial smoothing. In the case of standard quantum hydrodynamics, the ℏ≠0 dynamics of the Lagrangian path can be derived as a finite-dimensional canonical Hamiltonian system for the evolution of singular solutions called 'Bohmions', which follow Bohmian trajectories in configuration space. For molecular dynamics models, application of the smoothing process to a new factorization of the density operator leads to a finite-dimensional Hamiltonian system for the interaction of multiple (nuclear) Bohmions and a sequence of electronic quantum states.

Cesare Tronci (2019)Momentum maps for mixed states in quantum and classical mechanics, In: Journal of Geometric Mechanics American Institute of Mathematical Sciences

This paper presents the momentum map structures which emerge in the dynamics of mixed states. Both quantum and classical mechanics are shown to possess analogous momentum map pairs associated to left and right group actions. In the quantum setting, the right leg of the pair identifies the Berry curvature, while its left leg is shown to lead to different realizations of the density operator, which are of interest in quantum molecular dynamics. Finally, the paper shows how alternative representations of both the density matrix and the classical density are equivariant momentum maps generating new Clebsch representations for both quantum and classical dynamics. Uhlmann’s density matrix and Koopman wavefunctions are shown to be special cases of this construction.

J Gibbons, DD Holm, C Tronci (2007)Vlasov moments, integrable systems and singular solutions, In: Physics Letters A372(7)pp. 1024-1033 Elsevier

The Vlasov equation for the collisionless evolution of the single-particle probability distribution function (PDF) is a well-known Lie-Poisson Hamiltonian system. Remarkably, the operation of taking the moments of the Vlasov PDF preserves the Lie-Poisson structure. The individual particle motions correspond to singular solutions of the Vlasov equation. The paper focuses on singular solutions of the problem of geodesic motion of the Vlasov moments. These singular solutions recover geodesic motion of the individual particles.

U Amaldi, A Citterio, M Crescenti, A Giuliacci, C Tronci, R Zennaro (2007)CLUSTER: a high frequency H-mode coupled cavity linac for low and medium energies, In: Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment579(3)pp. 924-936

We propose an innovative linear accelerating structure, particularly suited for hadrontherapy applications. Its two main features are compactness and good power efficiency at low beam velocities: the first is achieved through a high working frequency and a consequent high accelerating gradient, the second is obtained by coupling several H-mode cavities together. The structure is called CLUSTER, which stands for "Coupled-cavity Linac USing Transverse Electric Radial field". In order to compare the performance of this structure with other hadrontherapy linac designs involving high frequencies, a conceptual study has been performed for an operating frequency of 3 GHz. Moreover a proof of principle has been obtained through RF measurements on a prototype operating at 1 GHz. An accelerator complex using a CLUSTER linac is also considered for protontherapy purposes. The whole complex is called cyclinac and is composed of a commercial cyclotron injecting the beam in a high-frequency linac.

DD Holm, V Putkaradze, C Tronci (2008)Kinetic models of oriented self-assembly, In: JOURNAL OF PHYSICS A-MATHEMATICAL AND THEORETICAL41(34)ARTN 34401 IOP PUBLISHING LTD
C Tronci, E Tassi, E Camporeale, PJ Morrison (2014)Hybrid Vlasov-MHD models: Hamiltonian vs. non-Hamiltonian, In: PLASMA PHYSICS AND CONTROLLED FUSION56(9)ARTN 09500 IOP PUBLISHING LTD
DD Holm, L Náraigh, C Tronci (2008)Emergent singular solutions of nonlocal density-magnetization equations in one dimension, In: Physical Review E (Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics)77(3)036211 American Physical Society

We investigate the emergence of singular solutions in a nonlocal model for a magnetic system. We study a modified Gilbert-type equation for the magnetization vector and find that the evolution depends strongly on the length scales of the nonlocal effects. We pass to a coupled density-magnetization model and perform a linear stability analysis, noting the effect of the length scales of nonlocality on the system’s stability properties. We carry out numerical simulations of the coupled system and find that singular solutions emerge from smooth initial data. The singular solutions represent a collection of interacting particles (clumpons). By restricting ourselves to the two-clumpon case, we are reduced to a two-dimensional dynamical system that is readily analyzed, and thus we classify the different clumpon interactions possible.

E Camporeale, Cesare Tronci (2017)Electron inertia and quasi-neutrality in the Weibel instability, In: Journal of Plasma Physics83(3)705830301 Cambridge University Press

While electron kinetic effects are well known to be of fundamental importance in several situations, the electron mean-flow inertia is often neglected when lengthscales below the electron skin depth become irrelevant. This has led to the formulation of different reduced models, where electron inertia terms are discarded while retaining some or all kinetic effects. Upon considering general full-orbit particle trajectories, this paper compares the dispersion relations emerging from such models in the case of the Weibel instability. As a result, the question of how lengthscales below the electron skin depth can be neglected in a kinetic treatment emerges as an unsolved problem, since all current theories suffer from drawbacks of different nature. Alternatively, we discuss fully kinetic theories that remove all these drawbacks by restricting to frequencies well below the plasma frequency of both ions and electrons. By giving up on the lengthscale restrictions appearing in previous works, these models are obtained by assuming quasi-neutrality in the full Maxwell-Vlasov system.

DD Holm, V Putkaradze, C Tronci (2007)Double bracket dissipation in kinetic theory for particles with anisotropic interactions, In: Proceedings of the Royal Society A466pp. 2991-3012

We derive equations of motion for the dynamics of anisotropic particles directly from the dissipative Vlasov kinetic equations, with the dissipation given by the double bracket approach (Double Bracket Vlasov, or DBV). The moments of the DBV equation lead to a nonlocal form of Darcy's law for the mass density. Next, kinetic equations for particles with anisotropic interaction are considered and also cast into the DBV form. The moment dynamics for these double bracket kinetic equations is expressed as Lie-Darcy continuum equations for densities of mass and orientation. We also show how to obtain a Smoluchowski model from a cold plasma-like moment closure of DBV. Thus, the double bracket kinetic framework serves as a unifying method for deriving different types of dynamics, from density--orientation to Smoluchowski equations. Extensions for more general physical systems are also discussed.

J Burby, Cesare Tronci (2017)Variational approach to low-frequency kinetic-MHD in the current-coupling scheme, In: Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion59(4)045013 IOP Publishing

Hybrid kinetic-MHD models describe the interaction of an MHD bulk uid with an ensemble of hot particles, which obeys a kinetic equation. In this work we apply Hamilton's variational principle to formulate new current-coupling kinetic-MHD models in the low-frequency approximation (i.e. large Larmor frequency limit). More particularly, we formulate current-coupling schemes, in which energetic particle dynamics are expressed in either guiding center or gyrocenter coordinates. When guiding center theory is used to model the hot particles, we show how energy conservation requires corrections to the standard magnetization term. On the other hand, charge and momentum conservation in gyrokinetic-MHD lead to extra terms in the usual de nition of the hot current density as well modi cations to conventional gyrocenter dynamics. All these new features arise naturally from the underlying variational structure of the proposed models.

K Noguchi, C Tronci, G Zuccaro, G Lapenta (2007)Formulation of the relativistic moment implicit particle-in-cell method, In: PHYSICS OF PLASMAS14(4)ARTN 04230 AMER INST PHYSICS
CESARE TRONCI, Ilon Joseph (2021)Koopman wavefunctions and Clebsch variables in Vlasov-Maxwell kinetic theory, In: Journal of Plasma Physics Cambridge University Press

Motivated by recent discussions on the possible role of quantum computation in plasma simulations, here we present different approaches to Koopman's Hilbert-space formulation of classical mechanics in the context of Vlasov-Maxwell kinetic theory. The celebrated Koopman-von Neumann construction is provided with two different Hamiltonian structures: one is canonical and recovers the usual Clebsch representation of the Vlasov density, the other is noncanonical and appears to overcome certain issues emerging in the canonical formalism. Furthermore, the canonical structure is restored for a variant of the Koopman-von Neumann construction that carries a different phase dynamics. Going back to van Hove's prequantum theory, the corresponding Koopman-van Hove equation provides an alternative Clebsch representation which is then coupled to the electromagnetic fields. Finally, the role of gauge transformations in the new context is discussed in detail.

Francois Gay-Balmaz, Cesare Tronci (2023)Dynamics of mixed quantum-classical spin systems, In: Journal of physics A, Mathematical and theoretical IOP

Mixed quantum-classical spin systems have been proposed in spin chain theory and, more recently, in magnon spintronics. However, current models of quantum-classical dynamics beyond mean-field approximations typically suffer from long-standing consistency issues, and, in some cases, invalidate Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. Here, we present a fully Hamiltonian theory of quantum-classical spin dynamics that appears to be the first to ensure an entire series of consistency properties, including positivity of both the classical and the quantum density, so that Heisenberg's principle is satisfied at all times. We show how this theory may connect to recent energy-balance considerations in measurement theory and we present its Poisson bracket structure explicitly. After focusing on the simpler case of a classical Bloch vector interacting with a quantum spin observable, we illustrate the extension of the model to systems with several spins, and restore the presence of orbital degrees of freedom.

Darryl D. Holm, Jonathan I. Rawlinson, Cesare Tronci (2021)The bohmion method in nonadiabatic quantum hydrodynamics, In: Journal of physics. A, Mathematical and theoretical54(49) IOP Publishing Ltd

Starting with the exact factorization of the molecular wavefunction, this paper presents the results from the numerical implementation in nonadiabatic molecular dynamics of the recently proposed bohmion method. Within the context of quantum hydrodynamics, we introduce a regularized nuclear Bohm potential admitting solutions comprising a train of delta-functions which provide a finite-dimensional sampling of the hydrodynamic flow paths. The bohmion method inherits all the basic conservation laws from its underlying variational structure and captures electronic decoherence. After reviewing the general theory, the method is applied to the well-known Tully models, which are used here as benchmark problems. In the present case of study, we show that the new method accurately reproduces both electronic decoherence and nuclear population dynamics.

Francois Gay-Balmaz, CESARE TRONCI (2022)Evolution of hybrid quantum–classical wavefunctions, In: Physica D, Nonlinear phenomena [e-journal]440133450 Elsevier

A gauge-invariant wave equation for the dynamics of hybrid quantum–classical systems is formulated by combining the variational setting of Lagrangian paths in continuum theories with Koopman wavefunctions in classical mechanics. We identify gauge transformations with unobservable phase factors in the classical phase-space and we introduce gauge invariance in the variational principle underlying a hybrid wave equation previously proposed by the authors. While the original construction ensures a positive-definite quantum density matrix, the present model also guarantees the same property for the classical Liouville density. After a suitable wavefunction factorization, gauge invariance is achieved by resorting to the classical Lagrangian paths made available by the Madelung transform of Koopman wavefunctions. Due to the appearance of a phase-space analogue of the Berry connection, the new hybrid wave equation is highly nonlinear and it is proposed here as a platform for further developments in quantum–classical dynamics. Indeed, the associated model is Hamiltonian and appears to be the first to ensure a series of consistency properties beyond positivity of quantum and classical densities. For example, the model possesses a quantum–classical Poincaré integral invariant and its special cases include both the mean-field model and the Ehrenfest model from chemical physics.

Giovanni Manfredi, Antoine Rittaud, Cesare Tronci (2023)Hybrid quantum-classical dynamics of pure-dephasing systems, In: Journal of physics A, Mathematical and theoretical IOP

Mixed quantum-classical spin systems have been proposed in spin chain theory and, more recently, in magnon spintronics. However, current models of quantum-classical dynamics beyond mean-field approximations typically suffer from long-standing consistency issues, and, in some cases, invalidate Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. Here, we present a fully Hamiltonian theory of quantum-classical spin dynamics that appears to be the first to ensure an entire series of consistency properties, including positivity of both the classical and the quantum density, so that Heisenberg's principle is satisfied at all times. We show how this theory may connect to recent energy-balance considerations in measurement theory and we present its Poisson bracket structure explicitly. After focusing on the simpler case of a classical Bloch vector interacting with a quantum spin observable, we illustrate the extension of the model to systems with several spins, and restore the presence of orbital degrees of freedom.

Francois Gay-Balmaz, Cesare Tronci (2022)KOOPMAN WAVEFUNCTIONS AND CLASSICAL STATES IN HYBRID QUANTUM-CLASSICAL DYNAMICS, In: Journal of geometric mechanics14(4)pp. 559-596 Amer Inst Mathematical Sciences-Aims

We deal with the reversible dynamics of coupled quantum and classical systems. Based on a recent proposal by the authors, we exploit the theory of hybrid quantum-classical wavefunctions to devise a closure model for the coupled dynamics in which both the quantum density matrix and the classical Liouville distribution retain their initial positive sign. In this way, the evolution allows identifying a classical and a quantum state in interaction at all times, thereby addressing a series of stringent consistency requirements. After combining Koopman's Hilbert-space method in classical mechanics with van Hove's unitary representations in prequantum theory, the closure model is made available by the variational structure underlying a suitable wavefunction factorization. Also, we use Poisson reduction by symmetry to show that the hybrid model possesses a noncanonical Poisson structure that does not seem to have appeared before. As an example, this structure is specialized to the case of quantum two-level systems.

Cesare Tronci (2023)Symplectic geometry and Koopman dynamics at the quantum-classical interface, In: The London Mathematical Society newsletter(505 ) London Mathematical Society
F Gay-Balmaz, TS Ratiu, C Tronci (2011)Equivalent theories of liquid crystal dynamics, In: arXiv

There are two competing descriptions of nematic liquid crystal dynamics: the Ericksen-Leslie director theory and the Eringen micropolar approach. Up to this day, these two descriptions have remained distinct in spite of several attempts to show that the micropolar theory comprises the director theory. In this paper we show that this is the case by using symmetry reduction techniques and introducing a new system that is equivalent to the Ericksen-Leslie equations and includes disclination dynamics. The resulting equations of motion are verified to be completely equivalent, although one of the two different reductions offers the possibility of accounting for orientational defects. After applying these two approaches to the ordered micropolar theory of Lhuiller and Rey, all the results are eventually extended to flowing complex fluids, such as nematic liquid crystals.

PJ Morrison, E Tassi, C Tronci (2013)Energy stability analysis for a hybrid fluid-kinetic plasma model, In: Nonlinear Physical Systems

In plasma physics, a hybrid fluid-kinetic model is composed of a magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) part that describes a bulk fluid component and a Vlasov kinetic theory part that describes an energetic plasma component. While most hybrid models in the plasma literature are non-Hamiltonian, this paper investigates a recent Hamiltonian variant in its two-dimensional configuration. The corresponding Hamiltonian structure is described along with its Casimir invariants. Then, the energy-Casimir method is used to derive explicit sufficient stability conditions, which imply a stable spectrum and suggest nonlinear stability.

ME Innocenti, C Tronci, S Markidis, G Lapenta (2016)Grid coupling mechanism in the semi-implicit adaptive Multi-Level Multi-Domain method, In: Journal of Physics: Conference Series719

The Multi-Level Multi-Domain (MLMD) method is a semi-implicit adaptive method for Particle-In-Cell plasma simulations. It has been demonstrated in the past in simulations of Maxwellian plasmas, electrostatic and electromagnetic instabilities, plasma expansion in vacuum, magnetic reconnection [1, 2, 3]. In multiple occasions, it has been commented on the coupling between the coarse and the refined grid solutions. The coupling mechanism itself, however, has never been explored in depth. Here, we investigate the theoretical bases of grid coupling in the MLMD system. We obtain an evolution law for the electric field solution in the overlap area of the MLMD system which highlights a dependance on the densities and currents from both the coarse and the refined grid, rather than from the coarse grid alone: grid coupling is obtained via densities and currents.

DD Holm, V Putkaradze, C Tronci (2011)Collisionless kinetic theory of rolling molecules, In: arXiv

We derive a collisionless kinetic theory for an ensemble of molecules undergoing nonholonomic rolling dynamics. We demonstrate that the existence of nonholonomic constraints leads to problems in generalizing the standard methods of statistical physics. In particular, we show that even though the energy of the system is conserved, and the system is closed in the thermodynamic sense, some fundamental features of statistical physics such as invariant measure do not hold for such nonholonomic systems. Nevertheless, we are able to construct a consistent kinetic theory using Hamilton's variational principle in Lagrangian variables, by regarding the kinetic solution as being concentrated on the constraint distribution. A cold fluid closure for the kinetic system is also presented, along with a particular class of exact solutions of the kinetic equations.

The Lagrange, Euler, and Euler-Poincar____'{e} variational principles for the guiding-center Vlasov-Maxwell equations are presented. Each variational principle presents a different approach to deriving guiding-center polarization and magnetization effects into the guiding-center Maxwell equations. The conservation laws of energy, momentum, and angular momentum are also derived by Noether method, where the guiding-center stress tensor is now shown to be explicitly symmetric.

The Vlasov equation for the collisionless evolution of the single-particle probability distribution function (PDF) is a well-known example of coadjoint motion. Remarkably, the property of coadjoint motion survives the process of taking moments. That is, the evolution of the moments of the Vlasov PDF is also coadjoint motion. We find that {____it geodesic} coadjoint motion of the Vlasov moments with respect to powers of the single-particle momentum admits singular (weak) solutions concentrated on embedded subspaces of physical space. The motion and interactions of these embedded subspaces are governed by canonical Hamiltonian equations for their geodesic evolution.

We formulate Euler-Poincar____'e equations on the Lie group Aut(P) of automorphisms of a principal bundle P. The corresponding flows are referred to as EPAut flows. We mainly focus on geodesic flows associated to Lagrangians of Kaluza-Klein type. In the special case of a trivial bundle P, we identify geodesics on certain infinite-dimensional semidirect-product Lie groups that emerge naturally from the construction. This approach leads naturally to a dual pair structure containing ____delta-like momentum map solutions that extend previous results on geodesic flows on the diffeomorphism group (EPDiff). In the second part, we consider incompressible flows on the Lie group of volume-preserving automorphisms of a principal bundle. In this context, the dual pair construction requires the definition of chromomorphism groups, i.e. suitable Lie group extensions generalizing the quantomorphism group.

A Citterio, U Amaldi, S Allegretti, P Bcrra, F Bourhaleb, S Braccini, M Crescenti, A Giuliacci, G Fagnola, P Pearce, S Toncelli, C Tronci, M Weiss, R Zennaro, E Rosso, B Szeless (2006)IDRA: An innovative centre for diagnostic and protontherapy, In: Frascati Physics Series40pp. 355-357

The IDRA project (fig.l) - The Institute for Diagnostic and RAdiotherapy - consists of a 30 MeV commercial cyclotron for the production of isotopes for PET, SPECT and other radionuclides for diagnostic and therapy combined with a proton linac for the treatment of deep seated tumours. A 3 GHz Side Coupled Linac named LIBO (Linac BOoster) post-accelerates the 30 MeV protons from the cyclotron up to 210 MeV in a length of 16.6 metres. The combination of a cyclotron and a linac has been dubbed "cyclinac".

The dynamics of quantum expectation values is considered in a geometric setting. First, expectation values of the canonical operators are shown to be equivariant momentum maps for the action of the Heisenberg group on quantum states. Then, the Hamiltonian structure of Ehrenfest's theorem is shown to be Lie-Poisson for a semidirect-product Lie group, named the `Ehrenfest group'. The underlying Poisson structure produces classical and quantum mechanics as special limit cases. In addition, quantum dynamics is expressed in the frame of the expectation values, in which the latter undergo canonical Hamiltonian motion. In the case of Gaussian states, expectation values dynamics couples to second-order moments, which also enjoy a momentum map structure. Eventually, Gaussian states are shown to possess a Lie-Poisson structure associated to another semidirect-product group, which is called the Jacobi group. This structure produces the energy-conserving variant of a class of Gaussian moment models previously appeared in the chemical physics literature.

F Gay-Balmaz, C Tronci (2011)Vlasov moment flows and geodesics on the Jacobi group, In: arXiv

By using the moment algebra of the Vlasov kinetic equation, we characterize the integrable Bloch-Iserles system on symmetric matrices (arXiv:math-ph/0512093) as a geodesic flow on the Jacobi group. We analyze the corresponding Lie-Poisson structure by presenting a momentum map, which both untangles the bracket structure and produces particle-type solutions that are inherited from the Vlasov-like interpretation. Moreover, we show how the Vlasov moments associated to Bloch-Iserles dynamics correspond to particular subgroup inclusions into a group central extension (first discovered in arXiv:math/0410100), which in turn underlies Vlasov kinetic theory. In the most general case of Bloch-Iserles dynamics, a generalization of the Jacobi group also emerges naturally.

U Amaldi, A Citterio, M Crescenti, A Giuliacci, C Tronci, R Zennaro (2007)CLUSTER: concept study and design of a low-medium beta accelerating structure, In: NUCLEAR PHYSICS B-PROCEEDINGS SUPPLEMENTS172pp. 277-279

Multipolar order in complex fluids is described by statistical correlations. This paper presents a novel dynamical approach, which accounts for microscopic effects on the order parameter space. Indeed, the order parameter field is replaced by a statistical distribution function that is carried by the fluid flow. Inspired by Doi's model of colloidal suspensions, the present theory is derived from a hybrid moment closure for Yang-Mills Vlasov plasmas. This hybrid formulation is constructed under the assumption that inertial effects dominate over dissipative phenomena, so that the total energy is conserved. After presenting the basic geometric properties of the theory, the effect of Yang-Mills fields is considered and a direct application is presented to magnetized fluids with quadrupolar order (spin nematic phases). Hybrid models are also formulated for complex fluids with symmetry breaking. For the special case of liquid crystals, the moment method can be applied to the hybrid formulation to study to the dynamics of cubatic phases.