Placeholder image for staff profiles

Dr Katherine Hubbard


Lecturer
+44 (0)1483 683964
08 AD 03

Biography

Research

Research interests

My teaching

My publications

Publications

Hubbard K, Hegarty P (2016) BLOTS AND ALL: A HISTORY OF THE RORSCHACH INK BLOT TEST IN BRITAIN, JOURNAL OF THE HISTORY OF THE BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES 52 (2) pp. 146-166 WILEY-BLACKWELL
Hegarty PJ, Hubbard K, Nyatanga L (2015) Innovative approaches to teaching CHIP: An introduction to the Special Issue, History and Philosophy of Psychology 16 (1) pp. 1-3 British Psychological Society
Hubbard Katherine (2017) Queer signs: The women of the British projective test movement, Journal of The History of the Behavioral Sciences 53 (3) pp. 265-285 Wiley
As queer history is often hidden historians must look for ?signs? that hint at queer lives and experiences. When psychologists use projective tests the search for queer signs has historically been more literal, and this was especially true in the homophobic practices of Psychology in the mid-20th century. In this paper I respond to Elizabeth Scarborough?s call for more analytic history about the lesser known women in Psychology?s history. By focusing on British projective research conducted by lesbian Psychologist June Hopkins I shift perspective and consider, not those who were tested (which has been historically more common), but those who did the testing, and position them as potential queer subjects. After briefly outlining why the projective test movement is ripe for such analysis and the kinds of queer signs that were identified using the Rorschach ink blot test in the mid-20th century, I then present June Hopkins? (1969; 1970) research on the ?lesbian personality?. This work forms a framework upon which I then consider the lives of Margaret Lowenfeld, Ann Kaldegg and Effie Lillian Hutton, all of whom were involved in the British projective test movement a generation prior to Hopkins. By adopting Hopkins? research to frame their lives I present the possibility of this ambiguous history being distinctly queer.
Hubbard Katherine, Hegarty Peter (2017) Rorschach tests and Rorschach vigilantes: Queering the history of Psychology in Watchmen, History of the Human Sciences 30 (4) pp. 75-99 Sage
One of the clearest signs that Psychology has impacted popular culture is the public?s familiarity with the Rorschach ink blot test. An excellent example of the Rorschach in popular culture can be found in Watchmen, the comic/graphic novel written by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons (1987). In the mid-20th century Psychology had an especially contentious relationship with comics; some psychologists were very anxious about the impact on comics on young people, whereas others wrote comics to subvert dominant norms about gender and sexuality. Yet historians of Psychology have had almost nothing to say about this popular and critically acclaimed novel. We read Watchmen here for its narratives that most concern the history of Psychology. We focus on such themes as anti-psychiatry, sexual violence, homophobia, lesbian erasure, and social psychological research on bystander intervention. We argue it is possible to more closely align Psychology and comics despite their sometimes contentious history. In doing so we demonstrate the active role of the public in the history of the Rorschach, public engagement of Psychology via comics, and also reveal what is possible when historians consider comics within their histories.
Hubbard K, de Visser R (2015) Not just bi the bi: the relationship between essentialist beliefs and attitudes about bisexuality, Psychology & Sexuality 6 (3) pp. 258-274 Taylor & Francis
In the literature about bisexuality few studies consider bisexual people?s beliefs about bisexuality and none examine essentialist beliefs about bisexuality. In the present study 244 participants (bisexual n = 58, lesbian/gay n = 54 and heterosexual n =132) from the UK were asked via online questionnaire about their attitudes towards bisexuality, homosexuality and heterosexuality, and how stable they perceived bisexuality, homosexuality and heterosexuality to be. They were also asked about their essentialist beliefs towards bisexuality. Bisexual respondents viewed bisexuality as significantly more stable than lesbian, gay and heterosexual respondents. Analysis also showed that less belief in the discreetness of bisexuality predicted more positive attitudes towards bisexuality, as did positive beliefs towards homosexuality and heterosexuality. Belief in the immutability of bisexuality did not, however, predict attitudes towards bisexuality. Therefore, discreteness appears to be an especially problematic essentialist belief about all sexual minorities, as it is consistently associated with negative attitudes. However, beliefs about the immutability of sexuality are not consistently associated with negative attitudes for all sexual minorities.
Hubbard Katherine (2017) Hooker, Evelyn (2 Sept. 1907?18 Nov. 1996), American National Biography Oxford University Press
Hooker, Evelyn (2 September 1907 ? 18 Nov. 1996) psychologist and key figure in the movement to depathologise homosexuality in the US, was born Evelyn Gentry in her grandmother?s one-room farm house in North Platte, Nebraska, the sixth of nine children of Edward and Jessie Bethel Gentry.
Hubbard K (2017) Treading on delicate ground: Comparing the lesbian and gay affirmative Rorschach research of June Hopkins & Evelyn Hooker, Psychology of Women Section Review 19 (1) pp. 1-9 British Psychological Society
?An old Victorian oil lamp. The shape of the lamp. Two girls - at each side going to kiss each other. Big breasts, very slim, high heads, only one leg. Red lipstick.? These are the responses to the above Rorschach ink blot (Card 3) by a woman ?who was deeply involved in a homosexual relationship? while at her stay in a psychiatric hospital in London (Barker, 1970). The use of the Rorschach in pathologising and affirmative research towards lesbians and gay men has had an interesting history. In this short paper I outline the work of two individual women ? Evelyn Hooker and June Hopkins- and compare their approaches to lesbian and gay affirmative research using the Rorschach. By paying close attention to the historical contexts of such research, I allow for new interpretations of the meaning of difference to emerge and suggest the projective test moment to be particularly rich for feminist scholars.
Hubbard Katherine (2018) The British projective test movement: Reflections on a queer feminist tale, History and Philosophy of Psychology 19 (1) British Psychological Society
In order to do queer history well a number of difficult challenges have to be overcome. Our understanding of sexuality has changed so much over time that historians must be careful and considerate when carving out ?queer? as a narrative. In this paper I will be outlining some of my analysis from my recent paper 'Queer signs: The women of the British projective test movement' in the Journal of the Behavioural Sciences and present some of the notable queer women involved in the early projective test movement. By paying attention to their queerness, in terms of their unusual and unconventional positions in a men-dominated early Psychology and their queer private lives, I add an additional lens through which we can consider early British Psychology. In reflection of this research I will draw upon two key issues central to this analysis. By reflecting upon the research project outlined here I argue it is not only important to recognise the work of these early queer women but
also celebrate their work, their resistance and their unconventionality.

Additional publications